“The Girl Who Waited”: A Doctor Who Review

Copyright 2005 by BBC.
Copyright © 2005 by BBC.

Amy: I’m gonna pull time apart for you.

One of my favorite episodes from Matt Smith’s run on Doctor Who is, ironically, one that features very little of the Doctor.  It’s a story that focuses on his companions Amy and Rory, and their love.  A story about time and broken promises and romance that overcomes bitter memories.

This is the Series 6 episode “The Girl Who Waited.”

What starts out as a side trip to a vacation on the planet Apalapucia becomes a nightmare when Amy finds herself separated from the Doctor and Rory.  At the Two Streams Facility, she ends up in an accelerated time stream, making her think the Doctor abandoned her for thirty-six years when he and Rory were only gone for a few minutes.  To protect herself from this alien hospital, Amy has grown bitter and violent, defending herself for what seemed like decades from deadly but well-meaning robots.  In the end, Rory has to deal with what his wife has gone through in her own time stream, the Doctor has to face a Companion who’s learned to hate him, and Amy has to reconcile her bitter memories with her deep-rooted love for Rory–all while trying to deal with the deadly hospital robots.

Copyright © 2011 by BBC.
Copyright © 2011 by BBC.

Honestly, when I watched this episode, the first thought that popped into my head was, “So, this is what happens when Doctor Who meets Portal.”  I mean, there’s a female protagonist who’s trapped inside an automated and well-lit facility, having to steal technology and fight against faceless robots and a supercomputer with a synthetic female voice.  Just swap out “time travel” for “teleportation” and it’d be the same story.  Not that I’m complaining, being a huge fan of both Who and Portal.

Beyond that geeky comparison, this story is low on monster scares and larger-than-life villains.  Its real strength is the tension between Rory, the Doctor, and Amy.  We’ve seen how the Doctor’s companions grow to trust him during their travels, and how some of them can even step in when the Doctor starts to go too far.  But what happens when a Companion thinks she’s been left behind or betrayed by the Doctor?  Karen Gillan’s performance as Amy gives us quite a stark answer: strong and resourceful like so many other companions, but without the compassion or friendship that defines them.

I also think Arthur Darvill brings a little more depth to Rory in this story.  While his role as a fighter is cemented thanks to his history as The Last Centurion, we get to see Rory more on his own.  The Doctor has to stay in the TARDIS, so Rory is the one using the sonic screwdriver and wearing “brainy specs.”  He’s the one who has to find Amy and then find a way to fix the time stream problem before they can all leave on the TARDIS.  It’s easy to sympathize with his plight, trying to reconcile what Amy goes through in her time stream with his faith in the Doctor and in her.

“The Girl Who Waited,” being a deconstruction episode of Who, gives the audience a lot of reasons to feel sad.  Watching three good friends fall apart over a time travel accident is hard, but the story is solid and so’s the acting.  And it wouldn’t be Doctor Who if the final act didn’t give us a solution that brings more tears.

Doctor Who is available on BBC One and BBC America.

Bibliography: “The Girl Who Waited.”  Doctor Who (Series 6).  Written by Tom MacRae.  Directed by Nick Hurran.  Produced by Marcus Wilson.  BBC TV.  Original broadcast: September, 10, 2011.


7 thoughts on ““The Girl Who Waited”: A Doctor Who Review

  1. I never had time to get into Dr. Who, making me a travesty of a sci fi fan to some, I imagine. Through your writing I was able to get a glimpse which reminds me of a plot in a much shorter running series, Fringe (I hope you don’t hate JJ Abrams!).
    The character Olivia Dunham is trapped in an alternate universe with her doppelganger despicably taking her place in a budding romance with Peter Bishop. When the universes are set right again with the proper Olivia and Fauxlivia back in their places of origin, the true emotional distress sets in for our female protagonist.
    I’ve watched the writers put the character of Olivia in some horrible situations, but I never saw her in this overwhelming kind of isolated pain in any of them.
    Being almost left behind from another family of time traveling, universe jumping characters.


    1. I’ve never watched Fringe myself, but I’ve heard good things. The plot does sound a lot like the time dissonance in this episode and certainly makes for good drama.

      Thanks for the comment, and thanks for reading!


  2. Andrea

    Excellent review. I have several friends who are not fond of this episode, mostly because of how Amy turns so quickly with in the episode, but after 36 years of loneliness who wouldn’t be bitter. I think Rory is definitely the compelling character in this story, especially more compelling than the Doctor. He still has this view of his wife and their lives together. Despite what has happened to Amy, he still loves her, no matter how old or bitter she has gotten. That’s real love. The ending truly gets me at the end because that is a situation that no one really ever wants to find themselves in: having to pick only one when you equally love both.


  3. Pingback: Doctor Who: The Girl Who Waited Review | The Consulting Detective

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s